Showing posts with label animal industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label animal industry. Show all posts

Monday, August 19, 2013

Hey, Tyson: What's your Beef with the Beef?

   Perhaps you have heard that Tyson Foods Inc. has stopped purchasing cattle that have been fed Zilmax, a feed additive meant to improve carcass quality.  The subsequent flood of news stories peppered with phrases like “beta-agonists,” “growth promotants,” and “animal welfare” can understandably raise questions from the public.  What are beta-agonists?  Are they safe for animals to consume?  If fed to an animal, is the meat safe for me to eat?  A very comprehensive article published by the American Society of Animal Science’s Taking Stock newsletter explains beta-agonists well.  The entire article can be found at http://takingstock.asas.org/?p=9145.  Here’s a brief summary of this article’s explanation of beta-agonists and what they do:

·         As animals mature, lean muscle is more difficult to produce than fat.  At the finishing stage (the time period before slaughter), beta-agonists encourage the formation of muscle mass rather than fat.  This means more lean meat (about 30 pounds per head of beef) will be available for the consumer.
·         Beta-agonists used for livestock are called ractopamine and zilpaterol hydrochloride; both are approved by the FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine.  While ractopamine can be used for swine and cattle, zilpaterol hydrochloride is only fed to cattle.  Its trade name, as sold by Merck & Co., is Zilmax.
·         Meat from beef cattle fed Zilmax is safe to eat.  Beta-agonists break down quickly before animals are slaughtered, and no human illnesses or ailments have ever been tied to the consumption of meat from Zilmax-fed cattle.
·         Tyson Foods Inc. has cited joint problems for its concern over cattle fed Zilmax with the logic that additional weight gained due to Zilmax would add pressure to joints.  However, no direct connection between Zilmax consumption and the loss of joint integrity has been found (McCurry-Schmidt, 2013).

   So there we are.  Zilmax is FDA-approved, increases the amount of lean muscle on a carcass and does not harm consumer health.  Of course, since the health of animals is a top priority for farmers and processors, the appearance of cattle with obvious joint problems has raised concerns.  According to a recent article in The Wall Street Journal, Merck & Co. will temporarily suspend sales of Zilmax and conduct studies on how the additive affects the health of cattle (Newman & Gee, 2013).  Research into this issue will hopefully reconfirm Zilmax’s safety, identify how it may affect cattle negatively, or reveal a different cause for joint problems.
   Of course, while all cases of endangered animal welfare are important, taking a “guilty until proven innocent” approach can trigger resentment from producers.  Cattle farmers all over the world have accepted the use of Zilmax for the last twenty years, the FDA has approved it in the U.S. since 2007, and documented research has supported its use for over 30 years (Rich, 2013).  Why, then, is the blame for beef cattle walking stiffly being thrown on Zilmax?  The National Cattlemen’s Beef Association CEO Forrest Roberts commented recently that specific additives “can be used responsibly when managed properly,” (Coffeen, 2013).  Providing cattle with the necessities to develop strong skeletons and feeding promotants for only a short time are parts of proper management; overuse of a muscle developer on an animal with a weak skeleton can understandably cause problems. 
   The world’s population is growing and, of course, needs to be fed.  Beef and pork are choice sources of nutrients are being demanded more and more by a growing middle class.  Being able to increase the yield-to-feed ratio for livestock will benefit producers, consumers, and animals as long as the means to do this are safe for all concerned.  To understand how much impact Zilmax or other additives can have on the beef supply, consider this quote from Richard Raymond, a former Undersecretary for Food Safety, USDA:

“If only half of the 24 million head of cattle harvested annually, a conservative estimate to be sure, yielded an additional 30 pounds of meat, this would provide 360 million more pounds of lean beef during a time when drought and high grain prices are forcing a reduction in the size of the American cattle herd. That would equate to 1.4 billion additional quarter pounders to help feed the world’s children, too many of whom go to bed hungry every night,” (Raymond, 2013).

References

Coffeen, Peggy.  (2013).  Tyson no longer taking cattle fed Zilmax.  Retrieved from http://www.agriview.com/news/livestock/tyson-no-longer-taking-cattle-fed-zilmax/article_130e0790-6166-5da2-bc5c-a7888abeee49.html.

McMurry-Schmidt, M. (2013, August 16).  What are beta agonists?  Taking Stock.  Retrieved from http://takingstock.asas.org/?p=9145.

Newman, J. & Gee, K.  (2013, August 18).  What’s ailing America’s cattle?  The Wall Street Journal.  Retrieved from http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323423804579020953889322782.html.

Raymond, R. (2013).  Having agony over the agonists?  Perspective from a former USDA Food Safety official.  Retrieved from http://factsaboutbeef.com/2013/08/02/having-agony-over-the-agonists-perspective-from-a-former-usda-food-safety-official/.


Rich, D. (2013, August 19).  Tyson to ban cattle fed with Zilmax.  High Plains/Midwest Ag Journal.  Retrieved from http://www.hpj.com/archives/2013/aug13/aug19/0813ZilmaxbanDRdbsr.cfm.

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Not in MY McNuggets!




Red flags unfurled and waved wildly in my mind when I saw this article from Food Safety Magazine: “High Arsenic Levels Found in U.S. Chicken.”  The original article can be viewed here: http://www.foodsafetymagazine.com/news/high-arsenic-levels-found-in-us-chicken/.  Now, arsenic can be a deadly thing; after all, it’s often the poison of choice in melodramas.  Just a small amount can be lethal: an oral dose of 60 mg is fatal to the average human (Minnesota Department of Health, 2012).  However, would companies really sell chicken meat that contains a known poisonous substance?  And just how reliable is the research that this article quotes?  Let’s take a closer look at the facts:

The Food Safety Magazine article alludes to “Arsenic species in poultry feather meal” published in a 2012 volume of Science of the Total Environment.  Rather than testing arsenic levels in chicken meat that would be directly eaten, the researchers looked at arsenic levels in feathers, which are not directly eaten by consumers.  The researchers reasoned that since feather meal is often used a protein source for fertilizers and animal feeds, the use of arsenic-tainted feather meal for these purposes could have harmful effects on humans.  This is a well-intentioned but perhaps unnecessary concern.  After all, the researchers found the concentration of inorganic arsenic in their samples was approximately 2 parts per billion (National Chicken Council, 2013).  The maximum contaminant level for arsenic in drinking water is 10 parts per billion (Environmental Protection Agency, 2012).  The average level of arsenic in soil is 3-4 parts per million (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, 2011).  Therefore, the chicken feathers contained less arsenic than may be found in both water and soil.

*             *             *

Another issue with the Science of the Total Environment article is the reference to the product roxarsone, allegedly added to the diets of broilers (chickens raised for meat production).  However, the researchers admitted that no connection between roxarsone and the presence of inorganic arsenic in feathers could be found:   

“In this study we had no information on the precise contribution of roxarsone to inorganic arsenic exposure in feather meal.” (Nachman, Raber, Frcesconi, Navas-Acien & Love, 2012).

Still, the researchers expressed their continued concern about the use of this product:

 “However, given the common use of roxarsone in poultry production, the increase in inorganic arsenic exposure in livers of chickens fed roxarsone, and the likely accumulation of inorganic arsenic in feathers, inorganic arsenic measured in feather meal in this study may have originated from the practice of administering roxarsone to broiler chickens in the context of industrial poultry production.” (Nachman, et al., 2012).

However, this concern is virtually unfounded today: since June 2011, roxarsone has no longer been used to supplement the diets of broilers (National Chicken Council, 2013). 

*             *             *

The last detail to raise doubt in this study is the relatively small sample size from which arsenic levels were determined.  Samples of feathers came from twelve locations: one each from Tennessee, Pennsylvania, California, and Idaho; two from Arkansas, four from Oregon, and two from China (Nachman, et al., 2012).  However, the specific locations and suppliers from whence the feathers came were not mentioned.  Basing analyses on such a small sample and not disclosing the origins of the sample materials is ill-practice in the world of peer-reviewed journals (Hofacre, 2012).  These samples might have all come from farms raising “free-range” broilers experiencing greater contact with soil and unregulated water sources, or from farms raising conventional broilers living in a controlled, indoor environment.  Such different rearing methods could arguably result in different levels of exposure to arsenic.

In conclusion, since arsenic is present in the air, water, and soil, it’s not surprising a small amount would end up on chicken feathers.  But remember, the arsenic levels found on the feathers were extremely low, and if contaminated feathers might pose a problem when added to fertilizers or animal feeds, they would not be added.  Given the thorough processing feathers endure before they are included in fertilizers or feeds, there is adequate time to check for feather quality and the presence of any contaminants (Moritz & Latshoaw, 2001). But again, the arsenic is appearing on feathers, not meat.  In fact, the U.S. Department of Agriculture monitors chicken meat for arsenic levels, and in the past 20 years has found zero samples that violate the level set by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (National Chicken Council, 2012).  With strict guidelines in place for levels of components in meat, milk, and all manner of animal products, the U.S. food supply is kept as safe as possible. 

References
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry.  (March 3, 2011).  Toxic substances portal – arsenic.  Retrieved from http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/phs/phs.asp?id=18&tid=3#bookmark03
Environmental Protection Agency.  (May 21, 2012).  Basic Information about arsenic in drinking water.  Retrieved from http://water.epa.gov/drink/contaminants/basicinformation/arsenic.cfm
Hofacre, C.L., (2012, April 24). Bloomberg chicken study is flawed.  The Baltimore Sun.  Retrieved from http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2012-04-24/news/bs-ed-chicken-study-letter-20120424_1_peer-review-chicken-samples
Minnesota Department of Health.  (November 21, 2012).  Arsenic.  Retrieved from http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/eh/hazardous/topics/arsenic.html#health
Moritz, J.S. & Latshaw, J.D.  (2001).  Indicators of nutritional value of hydrolyzed feather meal.  Poultry Science, 80, 79-86.
Nachman, K.E., Raber, G., Francesconi, K.A., Navas-Acien, A., & Love, D.C.  (2012).  Arsenic species in poultry feather meal.  Science of the Total Environment, 417-418, 183-188.
National Chicken Council.  (September 18, 2012).  Arsenic & chicken? No need to worry.  Retrieved from http://www.nationalchickencouncil.org/arsenic-chicken-no-need-to-worry/
National Chicken Council.  (May 11, 2013).  NCC responds to misleading Johns Hopkins study; says arsenicals no longer fed to broilers.  Retrieved from http://www.nationalchickencouncil.org/ncc-responds-to-misleading-johns-hopkins-study-says-arsenicals-no-longer-fed-to-broilers/
Minnesota Department of Health.  (November 21, 2012).  Arsenic.  Retrieved from http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/eh/hazardous/topics/arsenic.html#health